Mellocreme Autumn Mix 16 oz bag

All of your favorite autumn candies come together in this colorful color and chewy mix! Candy corn and Indian corn make a perfectly sweet candy mix to complete any fall harvest basket. The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Cand...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.99 On Sale [

Mellocreme Pumpkins 16 oz bag

These pumpkins have a soft and chewy texture and a sweet marshmallow flavor to make them a delicious and festive treat! The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Candy: more choices >>> Orders placed by midnight usually sh...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.99 On Sale [

Switzer's Cherry Bites 10 oz bag

Switzer's Cherry Bites. This American classic licorice disappeared in the mid-1990s and returned in 2005 with the same great taste. A 10 oz bag has about 120 pieces which are 3/4 inch long.Switzer's Licorice: more choices >>>Orders placed by...[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 [

Juju Coins - 2 lb bulk bag

These cherry-flavored Juju Candies are in the shape of coins from around the world. The larger coins are 1 inch in diameter. There are about 165 coins in a 2 lb bag.Juju Candy: more choices >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the ne...[Read More]
Our Price: $5.99 [

Caramel Apple Candy Corn 16 oz bag

Enjoy the classic taste of caramel and apples in these bite sized candy corn treats! The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Candy: more choices >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 On Sale [

Sweet Fall Jelly Beans 17 oz bag

These soft classic and chewy fall jelly beans come in an assortment of orange, yellow and black colors for a festive mix you are sure to love. The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Candy: more choices >>> Orders placed...[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 On Sale [

Twizzlers Strawberry Twists - wrapped - 1 piece

America's favorite strawberry twists… or is that Red Vines? The battle continues.Twizzlers: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.15 [

Fall Nonpareils 16 oz bag

Each dark chocolate disk is topped with colorful orange, yellow and white candy beads to make a sweet and crunchy treat that everyone will love! The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide and holds about 110 pieces. The Nonpareil is a little ...[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 On Sale [

Jelly Pumpkins 14 oz bag

These plump and colorful jelly pumpkins have a soft and chewy texture and are sanded with sugar for an extra sweet treat. Use these festive treats to complete any harvest basket. They are about 3/4 inch in diameter and 1/2 inch high. The bag is rough...[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 On Sale [

Peeps Marshmallow Pumpkins 24 ct box

These plump and colorful jelly pumpkins have a soft and chewy texture and are sanded with These light and fluffy marshmallow pumpkins make the perfect treat for your next autumn party or fall festival. Use these colorful marshmallow pumpkins in place...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.99 On Sale [

Gummi Pumpkin Heads 15 oz bag

Serve these fun plump colorful, and fruity pumpkins as a treat at your next autumn gathering, or add them to any harvest basket for a treat kids are sure to love. The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Candy: more choices >&g...[Read More]
Our Price: $2.99 On Sale [

Classic Gumball Machine Bank

At 12” tall, this old fashioned gumball machine is perfect for home, office or dorm room use. It’s also a great gumball machine for kids because it works as a gumball machine bank that helps teach how to save money. Kids of all ages love to put a coi...[Read More]
Our Price: $24.99 On Sale [

Dubble Bubble assorted flavors - 1 piece

Dubble Bubble assorted flavors which are watermelon, apple, grape and original.Dubble Bubble Gum: more sizes & flavors >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.10 [

Indian Corn 16 oz bag

Each colorful candy corn kernel has a soft and chewy texture and a deliciously sweet taste, making them the perfect candy to add to your fall harvest gift basket. The bag is roughly 6 inches high and 3 inches wide.Halloween Candy: more choices >&g...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.99 On Sale [

Toblerone 1.76 oz Milk Chocolate Bar

Swiss Milk Chocolate with Honey and Almond Nougat in a unique shape, packaged in the iconic triangle-shaped box. Each bar is 6.5 inches long.Toblerone: more sizes >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $1.69 [

Mint Twists - 1 piece

Mint Twists are peppermint candies similar to mint balls but in the shape of a small log that is about 1 inch long. Each twist is individually wrapped.Mint Twists: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day...[Read More]
Our Price: $0.10 [

Toblerone 1.76 oz Milk Chocolate Bar - box of 20

Swiss Milk Chocolate with Honey and Almond Nougat in a unique shape, packaged in the iconic triangle-shaped box. Each bar is 6.5 inches long.Toblerone: more sizes >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $27.99 [

Gift Certificate - $90.00

Not sure which Candy you ate as a kid® to get. How about a gift certificate for the Old Time Candy Company? Order like any product and it will be delivered by email within 1 business day after payment. Gift Certificates: more choices >>>...[Read More]
Our Price: $90.00 [

Candy Buttons - 2-piece pkg - box of 24

Candy Buttons are small buttons of candy that are attached to a strip of paper. Each 11 inch strip has three flavors: cherry (pink), lime (blue), and lemon (yellow).Candy Buttons: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the n...[Read More]
Our Price: $17.59 On Sale [

Peanut Brittle, Crispy Thin - 8 oz box - case of 12

Arnold's makes the best peanut brittle we have ever tasted. Crispy thin and loaded with peanuts... you will not be disappointed.Peanut Brittle: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day. ...[Read More]
Our Price: $29.99 On Sale [