Glass Candy Jar (Atomic Fire Balls)

This Candy Jar is filled with over 1.5 lbs of Atomic Fireballs in a reusable glass jar with chrome lid. The jar is 4.5 inches wide by 6.5 inches tall by 6.5 inches deep with a 3 inch opening. Use it over and over again, filled with your favorites. Th...[Read More]
Our Price: $23.99 [

Party Favor Prepack - Spring Bunnies

These Candy you ate as a kid® 10 oz party favors are prepacked with over 20 of the most popular candies. Each bag is about 9 inches high by 5 inches wide and is tied with a colorful bow. A typical candy list is below (additional info tab). Quanti...[Read More]
Our Price: $4.99 [

Chick-o-Sticks - 1 oz - 1 piece

Chick-O-Sticks are crunchy peanut butter and toasted coconut sticks. Each stick is 6 inches long.Chick-O-Sticks: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.49 [

Lunch Box - Minnie Mouse

Minnie Mouse Metal Lunch Box filled with Candy you ate as a kid.® This is a full size metal lunch box (like you took to school) that measures 8 inches wide, 7 inches tall and 4 inches deep. It is printed on all sides and has an identical, embosse...[Read More]
Our Price: $11.99 [

Nerds - grape and strawberry - 1.65 oz box - box of 24

Nerds are tiny, tangy, crunchy candy in grape and strawberry flavors. Nerds Candy: more sizes & flavors >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day. ...[Read More]
Our Price: $17.59 On Sale [

Mallo Cups - 1.6 oz 2-pack - box of 24

Mallo Cups are milk chocolate cups with a whipped creamy center and a sprinkle of coconut. There are 2 cups per package. Yes, they still come with the coupons.Mallo Cups: more sizes >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next busi...[Read More]
Our Price: $17.59 On Sale [

Gobstopper Pouches - 1 piece

Everlasting Gobstoppers are one of Willy Wonka's favorites. They are jaw breakers that change colors and flavors. Each pouch has about 8 pieces.Gobstoppers: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.39 [

Broadway Rolls (Danish Ribbons) - 2 oz strawberry roll

Over the years these ribbons of candy have been called different names, Delfa Rolls, Danish Ribbons or Broadway Rolls. After being discontinued a few years ago they are back and called Broadway Rolls again. Whatever you called them, these are the one...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.19 [

Atomic Fireballs - 1 piece

Atomic Fireballs... they don't call them fireballs for nothing! Basically a jawbreaker, these individually wrapped panned candies are about 3/4 inch in diameter. Atomic Fireballs: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the n...[Read More]
Our Price: $0.15 [

Cherry Mash - 2.05 oz bar - box of 24

Cherry Mash has soft cherry flavored center with real maraschino cherries covered in a mixture of chopped roasted peanuts and chocolate coating.Cherry Mash: more sizes >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $17.59 On Sale [

Lemonheads - 1 piece

Larger, wrapped Lemonheads which are panned candies with an tart lemon flavor, one of the first sour candies made.Lemonheads: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.10 [

Bubble Gum Cigars - original flavors - 1 cigar

Bubble Gum Cigars are 5 inches long and come in 3 flavors - banana, apple and fruit. Candy Cigarettes and Cigars: more choices >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.49 [

Moon Pie - Mini Chocolate - 1 piece

Just like the original chocolate Moon Pie only smaller.Moon Pies: more sizes & flavors >>> Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.55 [

Gift Certificate - $30.00

Not sure which Candy you ate as a kid® to get. How about a gift certificate for the Old Time Candy Company? Order like any product and it will be delivered by email within 1 business day after payment. Gift Certificates: more choices >>>...[Read More]
Our Price: $30.00 [

Rain-Blo - Sour Fruit Bubble Gumballs - wrapped - 1 piece

These assorted Rain-Blo Gum Balls are sour and individually wrapped.Rain-Blo Bubble Gum: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day....[Read More]
Our Price: $0.10 [

Mint Lumps by Bobs - 2 lb 10 oz box

Mint Lumps are hard candies with a peppermint taste and about 1.5 inches long. Each 2 lb 10 oz box has about 108 pieces.Candy Lumps: more choices >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day. ...[Read More]
Our Price: $11.99 [

Caramel Creams - 1 piece

Caramel Creams are sometimes called Bulls Eyes because of their look, caramel around the outside and a vanilla cream in the middle.Caramel Creams (Bull's Eyes): more sizes & flavors >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next b...[Read More]
Our Price: $0.25 [

Gummi Patriotic Stars - 2 lb bulk bag

These gummies have patriotic red, white, and blue star shapes. Every bite is soft and chewy with sweet fruit flavors. The stars are about 1 3/8 inches across (point to point). A 2 lb bag has roughly 117 pieces.Gummi Candy: more choices >>> O...[Read More]
Our Price: $7.99 [

Candy Buttons - 2-piece pkg

Candy Buttons are small buttons of candy that are attached to a strip of paper. Each 11 inch strip has three flavors: cherry (pink), lime (blue), and lemon (yellow).Candy Buttons: more sizes >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the n...[Read More]
Our Price: $1.19 [

Zotz - lemon-orange-grape - box of 48 strings

Zotz are a hard candy with a fizzy sour center. Each string has 4 pieces of a single flavor. There are about 16 strings of each flavor for a total of 192 pieces in each box.Zotz: more sizes & flavors >>>Orders placed by midnight usually ...[Read More]
Our Price: $14.39 On Sale [